Does Uncrustables Need to Be Refrigerated? How Long?

Uncrustables are tasty sandwiches made without crusts, and you customarily find them in the frozen section of grocery stores or supermarkets.

They are saleable and preferred by many consumers because they’re available in many different flavors.

The best options include strawberry or grape jelly, chocolate hazelnut spread, and classic peanut butter honey.

Undeniably, they are perfect snacks to serve for the whole family or when friends give you a surprise visit.

But the question is: Does uncrustables need to be refrigerated? For how long do you need to refrigerate them?

Read the post further to determine the answer to this question.

What Are Uncrustables?


What makes uncrustables sandwich a practical option is that they’re pre-made; therefore, they’re ready to eat, significantly cutting the time for snack or light meal preparations.

Besides the sandwich versions that feature various flavors, you can also enjoy the Uncrustables bites.

These delicious bread balls are made with a filling; nonetheless, they have different preparation methods than the original Uncrustables sandwiches.

Generally, you can purchase these pre-made snacks as frozen. As a result, they require minimal preparation techniques before you can eat them.

Do I Need to Refrigerate My Uncrustables?

It’s essential to store the uncrustables in the refrigerator if you’ve already thawed them. Be sure to consume them within six to eight hours.

Meanwhile, if you don’t plan to eat them right away, it’s best to keep them in the freezer.

Storing your uncrustables inside the freezer extends their shelf life more than thawing and refrigerating them.

In particular, you can extend your uncrustables’ shelf life to one year if you store them in the freezer.

Please note that it’s also vital to check the product’s expiration date, which is found on the package.

On the other hand, if you thaw your uncrustables, they’re likelier to last in the refrigerator for two hours.

For this reason, you should consume the thawed, uncrustable sandwiches immediately.

Unfortunately, if you don’t store them in the fridge, you can expect an extended shelf life, and their quality will significantly deteriorate.

How Long Can My Uncrustables Sit Out?


Uncrustables can sit out for only two to three hours at room temperature.

It’s worth noting that this period starts once the uncrustables sandwiches are thawed and prepared for consumption.

While the instructions on the product’s package lengthen the safe time for the uncrustables to sit out to 6 to 8 hours, it’s safer to adhere to the “two-hour rule” to ensure the product’s tiptop quality and flavorful taste.

How Can I Safely Store My Uncrustables In Lunch Boxes?

Undoubtedly, uncrustables are always a favorite when preparing your kid’s lunch boxes. But it’s critical to defrost them for a couple of hours and eat them at once.

It’s not advisable to defrost the uncrustables before packing them in lunch boxes.

The frozen sandwich will defrost shortly, making it no longer enjoyable for your kid to eat by that time.

If you want your sandwich to last longer, put it in a container with ice packs or a cooler, but consume it within six hours.

We strongly recommend using ice packs if you or your kid plans to eat the sandwich for later or if your kid will be out for an educational tour.

Is it okay to consume frozen uncrustables?

Yes. There’s no problem consuming frozen uncrustables. While they will be a bit more distinct than thawed, they will still taste delectable.

If you want to enjoy them better, consider putting them inside the oven on low heat or in the microwave uncrustables for a few seconds.

This method works like a charm in warming up the uncrustable sandwiches, giving them a fresh and more flavorful taste.

Ways to Check If the Uncrustables Have Gone Bad

Here are some of the things you can do to determine whether your uncrustables are safe to eat or not; inhibiting food poisoning concerns:

  • Observe if the bread is already stale or has a slimy texture.
  • Inspect if the sandwich already contains mold.
  • Examine if the bread appears wet or soggy.
  • If you’ve kept the uncrustables in the freezer, inspect if they have begun to thaw.
  • Check the product’s expiration date.
  • Thoroughly search if there’s a sour smell coming from the bread.
  • Observe if there’s a change in the color of the filling or bread.
  • If you’ve been keeping the uncrustables in the refrigerator, carefully examine if they began to freeze solid.
  • Check if the bread, such as the grape jelly sandwich, has lost its flavor.
  • Ensure that there’s no ice inside the uncrustables packet.
  • Consider contacting the manufacturer for any issues or queries.

Important Reminder: If you’re doubtful whether the bread has gone terribly, it’s best to discard the product and avoid taking chances, as doing so can compromise your health and safety.

Tips and Tricks to Make your Uncrustables Last Longer in the Kitchen Counter, Refrigerator, or Freezer:

1. Ensure that the pantry or kitchen counter used for thawing the uncrustables is neat and dry.

2. Thaw uncrustables in the packet or storage canister you usually use for homemade bread.

3. Thoroughly check the frozen uncrustables’ expiration date on the packet to ensure that it’s still fresh and suitable for safe consumption.

4. Avoid storing unrefrigerated uncrustables sandwiches or processed bread near humid areas or high-heat locations.

5. Use neat and dry materials, such as top-quality sandwich sealer, when storing the uncrustables if the packet tears.

What’s the Ideal Temperature For Uncrustables?

Ideal Temperature

The ideal and safest temperature for storing uncrustables for an extended period is 0°Fahrenheit.

In line with this, refrigerated uncrustables will stay safe at 34°Fahrenheit for 24 hours, even though it’s not appropriate for extended storage.

Final Thoughts

To conclude, uncrustables are excellent ways to savor a sandwich without undergoing strenuous and time-consuming preparations.

Such a product is effortless to store, and you can consume them thawed or frozen.

In the same way, you can choose from several different flavors, gratifying even the pickiest palate.

For all that, it’s decisive to follow proper storage instructions to extend the uncrustables’ shelf life and preserve their quality and taste.

So next time you prepare a straightforward and quick school lunch or snack to serve, give homemade uncrustables a try!

Hopefully, by reading our post about: “Do uncrustables need to be refrigerated,” you can enjoy this frozen sandwich at its best all the time!

Are you searching for an easier way to enjoy delicious and healthy meals? Look no further than Freezerfit! With access to more than 600 recipes, meal plans, and useful tips tailored for Keto, Vegan, Paleo, Gluten Free, and Vegetarian diets, this online service is just what you need.

Hi, I love to cook! I have been passionate about cooking for as long as I can remember. My favorite foods are Italian, Mexican, and Indian. I'm not afraid to share my love of cooking with my family, friends & the whole world.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.